In this week’s Golfweek Magazine (”The Forecaddie”, page 2), there is a short article describing a new PGA Tour policy regarding Monday qualifiers. I’ve confirmed the new policy through a contact at PGA Tour headquarters. Effective for the 2006 season, if you do not have the appropriate status on the PGA or Nationwide Tour, you will be required to pre-qualify for PGA Tour Monday qualifiers. “Appropriate status” generally means you have either conditional or exempt status one of these tours. This means the hundreds of mini tour players, myself included, that have a legitimate shot at qualifying for an event now have to make it through a pre-qualifier as well.
Adding an extra day - potentially at a course other than the qualifier course, requiring an extra practice round - is bad enough. If the pre-qualifier were the day before the Monday qualifier, this alone would make it impossible for a huge number of talented golfers to participate because certain mini tours have events that play their final round on Sunday. However, the PGA Tour has added an extra level of absolute lunacy to the new policy. The pre-qualifier is to be conducted the Wednesday before the Monday qualifier. This means that a mini tour golfer would need to:
- Not have an event the week prior to the PGA Tour Monday qualifier. Every significant US mini tour is either playing a tournament round or a practice round on Wednesday. Therefore, only players who have an off week the week of the Wednesday pre-qualifier would be able to compete.
- Not have an enormous travel burden to get to and from the pre-qualifier or Monday qualifier. Personally, I was only looking at 6 PGA Tour Monday qualifiers in 2006. Many were excluded because I would have to travel a huge distance the day before the qualifier.
- Not have an event on the day of the Monday qualifier.
- Accept sitting idle, often in a distant city with questionable practice privileges, for 5 days between the pre-qualifier and Monday qualifier.
Hopefully you’re starting to see the unrealistic barriers the PGA Tour has placed between a mini tour player and a PGA Tour Monday qualifier. However, this is only part of the issue.
The general opinion of mini tour players over the last few years is that Nationwide Tour events are becoming more difficult to Monday qualify for than PGA Tour events. This is an amazing trend since Nationwide Tour qualifiers usually have 14 spots available compared to 4 for PGA Tour qualifiers. I believe the fields play better in the Nationwide Tour qualifiers because:
- The entry fees are slightly less.
- The travel burden is generally easier.
- If you qualify, you only have to finish top 25 in the actual event in order to be exempted into the next week’s event. Only the top 10 are exempted on the PGA Tour.
- If you get hot and have a few good weeks, it’s easier to get special exempt status on the Nationwide Tour based on your earnings.
Now, with the new PGA Tour policy, a significant number of good mini tour players who would have played the PGA Tour qualifier will now enter the Nationwide Tour qualifier because they either can’t or don’t want to play the PGA Tour pre-qualifier. This means the Nationwide Tour qualifiers will have larger fields and deeper competition. So, now the mini tour player is logistically denied the opportunity to qualify for the PGA Tour and is up against longer odds in the Nationwide Tour qualifiers.
In addition, the PGA Tour is preparing to significantly decrease the number of events on its schedule. So, there will be even fewer opportunities for those who are able to manage the scheduling and try to participate. And, many of the PGA Tour Monday qualifiers are reducing - if not completely eliminating - the number of spots available from 4 to 3 or 2.
Also, consider that if a Nationwide Tour player - exempt or conditional - has a choice between a Nationwide or PGA Tour Monday qualifier, the player is almost always going to play the Nationwide Tour event. This is because the incremental dollars on the Nationwide Tour are more valuable to improving your status on that Tour and securing status via your year-end position on the money list. Because of this, few Nationwide Tour players will play the PGA Tour Monday qualifiers. The PGA Tour has created an absurd condition where only PGA Tour non-exempt members and (generally non-competitive) local golfers will compete in their qualifiers, not the mini tour players for whom the qualifiers are most appropriate. The system has been closed down significantly with this new policy.
A mini tour player already faced an uphill, expensive challenge to make it to the PGA or Nationwide Tours. Now, the PGA Tour has succeeded in making it even more difficult for anybody except those who are already there. I know I’m barking at the moon because the PGA Tour seems to make decisions that are not in the best interest of the game and without input from those whose careers they impact the most. Still, I feel the absurdity of the policy needs to be voiced.
What does this mean for the game? Well, the Q-School promotion system already is flawed in that it does not promote the players who play well for an entire year. It promotes the players who have a good week and don’t have a bad bounce during Q-School. The new Monday qualifier policy means that the players who are “hottest” at the time aren’t necessarily going to make it into a given tournament through the weekly qualifier. These hot players simply won’t be competing because its logistically not possible. I won’t even get into the financial barriers that exclude less privileged players from competing…there’s a reason you don’t see athletic inner city kids competing on the tour. As a fan you should realize that the Tour’s policies result in a product that does not showcase the best and deepest pool of talent in their events.
What’s the solution? Well, the PGA Tour only fields about 400 players in its “major league” (PGA Tour) and its “farm system” (Nationwide Tour). Compare this to the other major professional sports who all have significantly more players in the “system” and a relatively clear promotion path that is based mostly on performance - not mostly on luck. The Tour needs to cultivate and tie into probably 3-5 mini tours. These would feed into the Nationwide and PGA Tours based on performance over an entire season. Keep the PGA and Nationwide Tour sponsor exemptions for outstanding talent not otherwise exempt and expand Q-School. The new Q-School would provide a way to rank participants for all of the tours including the newly tied in mini tours (this accommodates the college kids). It would also give players a final shot at improving their ranking and moving up to a higher tour than what they qualified for with their seasonal performance. It would be appropriate for the mini tours to be relatively regional requiring some travel to approximate conditions on the PGA Tour. EVERY mini tour is chomping at the bit to build this kind of relationship with the PGA Tour. All that is required is for the PGA Tour to see the logic of this kind of system compared to the current one and take action.
Comments, questions…feel free to email me.